Romance and Politics
It’s campaign season and it’s killing me. In “real life” I’m a very opinionated person—just ask my friends and family. I can fulminate with the best of them and I have very definite political beliefs. All of which I have to leave at the door when I become Romance Writer.
When I taught at Enormous State University, I was always careful to keep my political opinions to myself. I didn’t want my students, many of whom held political opinions that were radically different from mine, to feel that they were in any danger of being persecuted for their beliefs. This was easier for me than for some of my colleagues since I taught things like document design and Web writing, where the subject of politics rarely came up (my friends in the history department were more hard pressed). Even so, I worked to keep my own opinions in the background. I knew what it was like to be on the receiving end of teacher prejudice more than once (when I was a kid, one teacher ridiculed me in front of my homeroom class for having a book about dinosaurs, which obviously meant I believed in (gasp) evolution).
Now as a novelist I’m in a somewhat similar position. I don’t want to limit myself to any particular group of readers, and I don’t want to exclude anyone from my books if I can help it. I’ve had some people complain about the sex scenes in my books, and I can’t do much about that (or anyway, I don’t intend to). Others have complained that my characters take the Lord’s Name in vain, and again I’m not going to change that since I want my dialogue to sound the way most people talk. But I try not to make my characters reflect any particular political agenda because as a reader I’ve been annoyed when authors did that. Some authors, like Jane Haddam, can get by with having political discussions in their work, but most of us can’t do it. I’ve found myself exasperated by characters in romance novels who suddenly start preaching about a particular social philosophy, and even more exasperated if the author inserts a hateful or absurd character who happens to share my own social philosophy. I abandoned one popular series when the author went out of her way to slam some political programs I happen to believe in. And that, of course, is the danger: when you step up on a soapbox, you risk alienating all the readers who don’t agree with you.
But my beliefs do show up in my books. My characters share my values—how could they not? When they stand up for something or against something, they’re reflecting my own ideas. So my leanings aren’t exactly a secret, even though they may not be blatantly expressed in my writing.
Still, at times like these I have a hard time keeping my mouth shut. Every day I hear things that I find outrageous and wrong. I’m longing to say something about it on Twitter or Facebook or MySpace, or to write a really blistering blog piece about the stuff that’s in the wind. But I won’t. Or anyway, I don’t think I will. The sound you hear is me, gritting my teeth so hard it hurts.
Posted in Blog • Tags: On Writing, politics, romance writing | 6 Comments
Ooh, that is a touchy subject, Meg. And I know of several authors who’ve caught hell for writing blog posts that reflected an unpopular opinion.
I generally try to limit my personal political statements to topics about which I feel so passionate that I don’t really care if I lose readers who don’t agree with me. Although, to be honest, I doubt many of them are reading me anyway.
I will say though that my characters don’t always reflect my personal beliefs. In my Oberon series, in fact, my characters frequently found themselves on opposite sides of many a political fence. It was actually quite fun for me to watch them bicker and to try and sympathize w/ two different world views at once.
Ah, PG, I envy you! These days trying to have enough empathy with your opponents to give fair representation of their views is sometimes tough. But somehow Jane Haddam usually success, although I doubt I would.
Seriously? People have complained about your sex scenes? And taking the Lord’s name in vain? There are people who have strong feelings about some things, clearly. Sharing values like love and family and honesty and freedom and integrity isn’t likely to alienate too many people – but there are definitely touchy political topics that I too try to avoid, and I too have backed away from authors who’ve supported things I don’t believe in. I’m pretty easygoing but there are some things I also have strong feelings on – but sex and swearing aren’t some of them.
Well, in the immortal words of Ricky Nelson, “You can’t please everybody–got to please yourself!”
I just think if people are so intolerant they need to write their own books. Otherwise, I think they need to remember it’s a work of fiction and enjoy the story without getting uptight that something the character did or said wasn’t something they would do or say. In other words, I might have to say, “Reader, lighten up.”
True, sometimes it’s just a reader with a personal ax to grind, in which case there’s not much you can do about it anyway.